**10 Myths That Hold Bright Math Students Back**

These widely-held beliefs lead to decisions that prevent bright students from reaching

their full mathematical potential. Each holds a grain of truth but hides a deeper truth.

** Myth 1: Math is mainly about performing procedures accurately and quickly.**

*A grain of truth: *Procedural fluency is one of many components of math proficiency*.The deeper truth: *Math is mainly about understanding, creating, and reasoning about patterns and relationships.

** Myth 2: Mathematically talented people have special abilities that ordinary people lack.**

*A grain of truth: *People have different capacities for understanding and doing math.*The deeper truth: *Math ability is changeable, and most people, bright ones included, greatly underestimate their mathematical potential.** **

**Myth 3: Acceleration is highly effective in meeting the needs of bright math students.**

*A grain of truth: *Acceleration meets some needs of some bright math students.*The deeper truth: *Acceleration as typically practiced *inhibits* many students’ learning and growth in math.

**Myth 4: Skill-based math tests can effectively measure bright students’ abilities and learning.**

*A grain of truth: *Skill-based math tests provide some insight into bright students’ abilities and learning.*The deeper truth: *Skill-based math tests alone are insufficient and are often misinterpreted.

**Myth 5: Elementary teachers do not need to understand math deeply.**

*A grain of truth: *Elementary teachers do not need extensive knowledge of secondary mathematics.*The deeper truth: *All math teachers need and can gain deep knowledge around the content that they teach.

**Myth 6: Bright math students’ needs can be met entirely within mixed-ability classrooms.**

*A grain of truth: *All students can benefit when bright students take part in mixed-ability math classrooms.*The deeper truth:* Bright math students also need frequent, focused opportunities to talk and work with others who are thinking at similar levels.

**Myth 7: Identifying needs of bright math students is necessarily harmful and elitist.**

*A grain of truth: *Elitism exists in gifted education and has negative consequences.*The deeper truth: *Identifying bright math students and meeting their needs can support *all* students’ learning.

**Myth 8: Bright math students learn best from tasks just beyond their comfort level.**

*A grain of truth: *Students should work only on math tasks that they can make sense of.*The deeper truth: Highly* challenging tasks also play an important role in meeting the needs of bright math students.

** Myth 9: Bright students can learn math on their own.**

*A grain of truth: *Many bright students are good at learning certain aspects of math independently.*The deeper truth: *Nearly all math students need significant guidance in order to fully develop their potential.

**Myth 10: Bright math students deserve special opportunities and experiences.**

*A grain of truth: *Bright math students, like all others, benefit from having a range of choices and opportunities.*The deeper truth: *Experiences that target a student’s needs should be treated as neither optional nor special.

This list is meant to spark conversation.

**Questions to Consider**What does the myth sound and look like?

What are the consequences?

What can I do?